Does Recycling Cause You To Consume More?

Submitted: The Two Sides Team March 14, 2013

A lot of eco-minded people will avoid purchasing items that they know will end up in the garbage. But do they also react in the opposite way by consuming more when they know that something will be recycled?
March 12, 2013

by John Platt, via MNN

A lot of eco-minded people will avoid purchasing items that they
know will end up in the garbage. But do they also react in the opposite
way by consuming more when they know that something will be recycled? That seems to be the indication from a study published recently in the Journal of Consumer Psychology.

The research was conducted by Jesse Catlin, an assistant professor at Washington State University Tri-Cities, and Yitong Wang,
an assistant professor at Tsinghua University in Beijing, China. They
conducted two experiments to find out how much paper people used if they
had the option to recycle their waste. The studies were partially
funded by the project was funded in part by the Newkirk Center for Science and Society, which focuses on issues such as health and the environment as they related to community and quality of life.

In the first experiment, two groups of graduate students who did
not know the nature of the study were given the task of evaluating a
pair of scissors by cutting up as much paper as they could, then
disposing of the paper. One group had a waste basket for that part of
the task, while the second group had both a wastebasket and a recycling
bucket. The group that had an option to throw their waste out in a
recycling bucket chopped up nearly three times as much paper.

In the second experiment the researchers staked out a men’s room
for 30 days and monitored how many paper towels were used. For the first
15 days of the experiment the restroom only has a waste basket. For the
second 15 days, they added a recycling bin. They amount of paper used
per person during the second 15 days was 14 percent more.

The researchers calculated that the restroom would use 12,500 more paper towels per year in the second scenario.

The researchers also asked their undergrads who conducted the
scissor experiment to fill out a questionnaire about their “green”
behaviors. They linked the answers with previous studies that showed how
people who try to behave in an eco-friendly manner often trade off and
rationalize their behavior, such as saying it is okay to do a non-green
thing because something else they do balances it out. In this case, they
concluded that the people in the experiment used the recycling option
as a way to allow themselves to use more waste because it was going to
be recycled.

As the authors write, “we propose that the ability to recycle may
lead to increased resource usage compared to when a recycling option is
not available.” They say their paper has potential implications for
further research and for policy-making, such as whether or not recycling
should be available in certain situations.